OneSidedFrequentistUpperLimitWithBands.C

Go to the documentation of this file.

/// \file
/// \ingroup tutorial_roostats
/// \notebook
/// OneSidedFrequentistUpperLimitWithBands
///
/// This is a standard demo that can be used with any ROOT file
/// prepared in the standard way.  You specify:
///  - name for input ROOT file
///  - name of workspace inside ROOT file that holds model and data
///  - name of ModelConfig that specifies details for calculator tools
///  - name of dataset
///
/// With default parameters the macro will attempt to run the
/// standard hist2workspace example and read the ROOT file
/// that it produces.
///
/// The first ~100 lines define a new test statistic, then the main macro starts.
/// You may want to control:
/// ~~~{.cpp}
///   double confidenceLevel=0.95;
///   int nPointsToScan = 12;
///   int nToyMC = 150;
/// ~~~
/// This uses a modified version of the profile likelihood ratio as
/// a test statistic for upper limits (eg. test stat = 0 if muhat>mu).
///
/// Based on the observed data, one defines a set of parameter points
/// to be tested based on the value of the parameter of interest
/// and the conditional MLE (eg. profiled) values of the nuisance parameters.
///
/// At each parameter point, pseudo-experiments are generated using this
/// fixed reference model and then the test statistic is evaluated.
/// Note, the nuisance parameters are floating in the fits.  For each point,
/// the threshold that defines the 95% acceptance region is found.  This
/// forms a "Confidence Belt".
///
/// After constructing the confidence belt, one can find the confidence
/// interval for any particular dataset by finding the intersection
/// of the observed test statistic and the confidence belt.  First
/// this is done on the observed data to get an observed 1-sided upper limt.
///
/// Finally, there expected limit and bands (from background-only) are
/// formed by generating background-only data and finding the upper limit.
/// This is done by hand for now, will later be part of the RooStats tools.
///
/// On a technical note, this technique is NOT the Feldman-Cousins technique,
/// because that is a 2-sided interval BY DEFINITION.  However, like the
/// Feldman-Cousins technique this is a Neyman-Construction.  For technical
/// reasons the easiest way to implement this right now is to use the
/// FeldmanCousins tool and then change the test statistic that it is using.
///
/// Building the confidence belt can be computationally expensive.  Once it is built,
/// one could save it to a file and use it in a separate step.
///
/// We can use PROOF to speed things along in parallel, however,
/// the test statistic has to be installed on the workers
/// so either turn off PROOF or include the modified test statistic
/// in your `$ROOTSYS/roofit/roostats/inc` directory,
/// add the additional line to the LinkDef.h file,
/// and recompile root.
///
/// Note, if you have a boundary on the parameter of interest (eg. cross-section)
/// the threshold on the one-sided test statistic starts off very small because we
/// are only including downward fluctuations.  You can see the threshold in these printouts:
/// ~~~{.cpp}
/// [#0] PROGRESS:Generation -- generated toys: 500 / 999
/// NeymanConstruction: Prog: 12/50 total MC = 39 this test stat = 0
///  SigXsecOverSM=0.69 alpha_syst1=0.136515 alpha_syst3=0.425415 beta_syst2=1.08496 [-1e+30, 0.011215]  in interval = 1
/// ~~~
/// this tells you the values of the parameters being used to generate the pseudo-experiments
/// and the threshold in this case is 0.011215.  One would expect for 95% that the threshold
/// would be ~1.35 once the cross-section is far enough away from 0 that it is essentially
/// unaffected by the boundary.  As one reaches the last points in the scan, the
/// threshold starts to get artificially high.  This is because the range of the parameter in
/// the fit is the same as the range in the scan.  In the future, these should be independently
/// controlled, but they are not now.  As a result the ~50% of pseudo-experiments that have an
/// upward fluctuation end up with muhat = muMax.  Because of this, the upper range of the
/// parameter should be well above the expected upper limit... but not too high or one will
/// need a very large value of nPointsToScan to resolve the relevant region.  This can be
/// improved, but this is the first version of this script.
///
/// Important note: when the model includes external constraint terms, like a Gaussian
/// constraint to a nuisance parameter centered around some nominal value there is
/// a subtlety.  The asymptotic results are all based on the assumption that all the
/// measurements fluctuate... including the nominal values from auxiliary measurements.
/// If these do not fluctuate, this corresponds to an "conditional ensemble".  The
/// result is that the distribution of the test statistic can become very non-chi^2.
/// This results in thresholds that become very large. This can be seen in the following
/// thought experiment.  Say the model is
/// \f$ Pois(N | s + b)G(b0|b,sigma) \f$
/// where \f$ G(b0|b,sigma) \f$ is the external constraint and b0 is 100.  If N is also 100
/// then the profiled value of b given s is going to be some trade off between 100-s and b0.
/// If sigma is \f$ \sqrt(N) \f$, then the profiled value of b is probably 100 - s/2   So for
/// s=60 we are going to have a profiled value of b~70.  Now when we generate pseudo-experiments
/// for s=60, b=70 we will have N~130 and the average shat will be 30, not 60.  In practice,
/// this is only an issue for values of s that are very excluded.  For values of s near the 95%
/// limit this should not be a big effect.  This can be avoided if the nominal values of the constraints also fluctuate,
/// but that requires that those parameters are RooRealVars in the model.
/// This version does not deal with this issue, but it will be addressed in a future version.
///
/// \macro_image
/// \macro_output
/// \macro_code
///
/// \authors Kyle Cranmer, Haichen Wang, Daniel Whiteson
 
#include "TFile.h"
#include "TROOT.h"
#include "TH1F.h"
#include "TCanvas.h"
#include "TSystem.h"
 
#include "RooWorkspace.h"
#include "RooSimultaneous.h"
#include "RooAbsData.h"
 
#include "RooStats/ModelConfig.h"
#include "RooStats/FeldmanCousins.h"
#include "RooStats/ToyMCSampler.h"
#include "RooStats/PointSetInterval.h"
#include "RooStats/ConfidenceBelt.h"
 
#include "RooStats/RooStatsUtils.h"
#include "RooStats/ProfileLikelihoodTestStat.h"
 
using namespace RooFit;
using namespace RooStats;
 
bool useProof = false; // flag to control whether to use Proof
int nworkers = 0;      // number of workers (default use all available cores)
 
// -------------------------------------------------------
// The actual macro
 
void OneSidedFrequentistUpperLimitWithBands(const char *infile = "", const char *workspaceName = "combined",
                                            const char *modelConfigName = "ModelConfig",
                                            const char *dataName = "obsData")
{
 
   double confidenceLevel = 0.95;
   int nPointsToScan = 12;
   int nToyMC = 150;
 
   // -------------------------------------------------------
   // First part is just to access a user-defined file
   // or create the standard example file if it doesn't exist
   const char *filename = "";
   if (!strcmp(infile, "")) {
      filename = "results/example_combined_GaussExample_model.root";
      bool fileExist = !gSystem->AccessPathName(filename); // note opposite return code
      // if file does not exists generate with histfactory
      if (!fileExist) {
         // Normally this would be run on the command line
         cout << "will run standard hist2workspace example" << endl;
         gROOT->ProcessLine(".! prepareHistFactory .");
         gROOT->ProcessLine(".! hist2workspace config/example.xml");
         cout << "\n\n---------------------" << endl;
         cout << "Done creating example input" << endl;
         cout << "---------------------\n\n" << endl;
      }
 
   } else
      filename = infile;
 
   // Try to open the file
   TFile *file = TFile::Open(filename);
 
   // if input file was specified byt not found, quit
   if (!file) {
      cout << "StandardRooStatsDemoMacro: Input file " << filename << " is not found" << endl;
      return;
   }
 
   // -------------------------------------------------------
   // Now get the data and workspace
 
   // get the workspace out of the file
   RooWorkspace *w = (RooWorkspace *)file->Get(workspaceName);
   if (!w) {
      cout << "workspace not found" << endl;
      return;
   }
 
   // get the modelConfig out of the file
   ModelConfig *mc = (ModelConfig *)w->obj(modelConfigName);
 
   // get the modelConfig out of the file
   RooAbsData *data = w->data(dataName);
 
   // make sure ingredients are found
   if (!data || !mc) {
      w->Print();
      cout << "data or ModelConfig was not found" << endl;
      return;
   }
 
   // -------------------------------------------------------
   // Now get the POI for convenience
   // you may want to adjust the range of your POI
 
   RooRealVar *firstPOI = (RooRealVar *)mc->GetParametersOfInterest()->first();
   /*  firstPOI->setMin(0);*/
   /*  firstPOI->setMax(10);*/
 
   // --------------------------------------------
   // Create and use the FeldmanCousins tool
   // to find and plot the 95% confidence interval
   // on the parameter of interest as specified
   // in the model config
   // REMEMBER, we will change the test statistic
   // so this is NOT a Feldman-Cousins interval
   FeldmanCousins fc(*data, *mc);
   fc.SetConfidenceLevel(confidenceLevel);
   fc.AdditionalNToysFactor(
      0.5); // degrade/improve sampling that defines confidence belt: in this case makes the example faster
   /*  fc.UseAdaptiveSampling(true); // speed it up a bit, don't use for expected limits*/
   fc.SetNBins(nPointsToScan); // set how many points per parameter of interest to scan
   fc.CreateConfBelt(true);    // save the information in the belt for plotting
 
   // -------------------------------------------------------
   // Feldman-Cousins is a unified limit by definition
   // but the tool takes care of a few things for us like which values
   // of the nuisance parameters should be used to generate toys.
   // so let's just change the test statistic and realize this is
   // no longer "Feldman-Cousins" but is a fully frequentist Neyman-Construction.
   /*  ProfileLikelihoodTestStatModified onesided(*mc->GetPdf());*/
   /*  fc.GetTestStatSampler()->SetTestStatistic(&onesided);*/
   /* ((ToyMCSampler*) fc.GetTestStatSampler())->SetGenerateBinned(true); */
   ToyMCSampler *toymcsampler = (ToyMCSampler *)fc.GetTestStatSampler();
   ProfileLikelihoodTestStat *testStat = dynamic_cast<ProfileLikelihoodTestStat *>(toymcsampler->GetTestStatistic());
   testStat->SetOneSided(true);
 
   // Since this tool needs to throw toy MC the PDF needs to be
   // extended or the tool needs to know how many entries in a dataset
   // per pseudo experiment.
   // In the 'number counting form' where the entries in the dataset
   // are counts, and not values of discriminating variables, the
   // datasets typically only have one entry and the PDF is not
   // extended.
   if (!mc->GetPdf()->canBeExtended()) {
      if (data->numEntries() == 1)
         fc.FluctuateNumDataEntries(false);
      else
         cout << "Not sure what to do about this model" << endl;
   }
 
   // We can use PROOF to speed things along in parallel
   // However, the test statistic has to be installed on the workers
   // so either turn off PROOF or include the modified test statistic
   // in your `$ROOTSYS/roofit/roostats/inc` directory,
   // add the additional line to the LinkDef.h file,
   // and recompile root.
   if (useProof) {
      ProofConfig pc(*w, nworkers, "", false);
      toymcsampler->SetProofConfig(&pc); // enable proof
   }
 
   if (mc->GetGlobalObservables()) {
      cout << "will use global observables for unconditional ensemble" << endl;
      mc->GetGlobalObservables()->Print();
      toymcsampler->SetGlobalObservables(*mc->GetGlobalObservables());
   }
 
   // Now get the interval
   PointSetInterval *interval = fc.GetInterval();
   ConfidenceBelt *belt = fc.GetConfidenceBelt();
 
   // print out the interval on the first Parameter of Interest
   cout << "\n95% interval on " << firstPOI->GetName() << " is : [" << interval->LowerLimit(*firstPOI) << ", "
        << interval->UpperLimit(*firstPOI) << "] " << endl;
 
   // get observed UL and value of test statistic evaluated there
   RooArgSet tmpPOI(*firstPOI);
   double observedUL = interval->UpperLimit(*firstPOI);
   firstPOI->setVal(observedUL);
   double obsTSatObsUL = fc.GetTestStatSampler()->EvaluateTestStatistic(*data, tmpPOI);
 
   // Ask the calculator which points were scanned
   RooDataSet *parameterScan = (RooDataSet *)fc.GetPointsToScan();
   RooArgSet *tmpPoint;
 
   // make a histogram of parameter vs. threshold
   TH1F *histOfThresholds =
      new TH1F("histOfThresholds", "", parameterScan->numEntries(), firstPOI->getMin(), firstPOI->getMax());
   histOfThresholds->GetXaxis()->SetTitle(firstPOI->GetName());
   histOfThresholds->GetYaxis()->SetTitle("Threshold");
 
   // loop through the points that were tested and ask confidence belt
   // what the upper/lower thresholds were.
   // For FeldmanCousins, the lower cut off is always 0
   for (Int_t i = 0; i < parameterScan->numEntries(); ++i) {
      tmpPoint = (RooArgSet *)parameterScan->get(i)->clone("temp");
      // cout <<"get threshold"<<endl;
      double arMax = belt->GetAcceptanceRegionMax(*tmpPoint);
      double poiVal = tmpPoint->getRealValue(firstPOI->GetName());
      histOfThresholds->Fill(poiVal, arMax);
   }
   TCanvas *c1 = new TCanvas();
   c1->Divide(2);
   c1->cd(1);
   histOfThresholds->SetMinimum(0);
   histOfThresholds->Draw();
   c1->cd(2);
 
   // -------------------------------------------------------
   // Now we generate the expected bands and power-constraint
 
   // First: find parameter point for mu=0, with conditional MLEs for nuisance parameters
   std::unique_ptr<RooAbsReal> nll{mc->GetPdf()->createNLL(*data)};
   std::unique_ptr<RooAbsReal> profile{nll->createProfile(*mc->GetParametersOfInterest())};
   firstPOI->setVal(0.);
   profile->getVal(); // this will do fit and set nuisance parameters to profiled values
   RooArgSet *poiAndNuisance = new RooArgSet();
   if (mc->GetNuisanceParameters())
      poiAndNuisance->add(*mc->GetNuisanceParameters());
   poiAndNuisance->add(*mc->GetParametersOfInterest());
   w->saveSnapshot("paramsToGenerateData", *poiAndNuisance);
   RooArgSet *paramsToGenerateData = (RooArgSet *)poiAndNuisance->snapshot();
   cout << "\nWill use these parameter points to generate pseudo data for bkg only" << endl;
   paramsToGenerateData->Print("v");
 
   RooArgSet unconditionalObs;
   unconditionalObs.add(*mc->GetObservables());
   unconditionalObs.add(*mc->GetGlobalObservables()); // comment this out for the original conditional ensemble
 
   double CLb = 0;
   double CLbinclusive = 0;
 
   // Now we generate background only and find distribution of upper limits
   TH1F *histOfUL = new TH1F("histOfUL", "", 100, 0, firstPOI->getMax());
   histOfUL->GetXaxis()->SetTitle("Upper Limit (background only)");
   histOfUL->GetYaxis()->SetTitle("Entries");
   for (int imc = 0; imc < nToyMC; ++imc) {
 
      // set parameters back to values for generating pseudo data
      //    cout << "\n get current nuis, set vals, print again" << endl;
      w->loadSnapshot("paramsToGenerateData");
      //    poiAndNuisance->Print("v");
 
      std::unique_ptr<RooDataSet> toyData;
      // now generate a toy dataset
      if (!mc->GetPdf()->canBeExtended()) {
         if (data->numEntries() == 1)
            toyData = std::unique_ptr<RooDataSet>{mc->GetPdf()->generate(*mc->GetObservables(), 1)};
         else
            cout << "Not sure what to do about this model" << endl;
      } else {
         //      cout << "generating extended dataset"<<endl;
         toyData = std::unique_ptr<RooDataSet>{mc->GetPdf()->generate(*mc->GetObservables(), Extended())};
      }
 
      // generate global observables
      // need to be careful for simpdf
      //    RooDataSet* globalData = mc->GetPdf()->generate(*mc->GetGlobalObservables(),1);
 
      RooSimultaneous *simPdf = dynamic_cast<RooSimultaneous *>(mc->GetPdf());
      if (!simPdf) {
         std::unique_ptr<RooDataSet> one{mc->GetPdf()->generate(*mc->GetGlobalObservables(), 1)};
         const RooArgSet *values = one->get();
         std::unique_ptr<RooArgSet> allVars{mc->GetPdf()->getVariables()};
         allVars->assign(*values);
      } else {
 
         // try fix for sim pdf
         for (auto const& tt : simPdf->indexCat()) {
            auto const& catName = tt.first;
 
            // Get pdf associated with state from simpdf
            RooAbsPdf *pdftmp = simPdf->getPdf(catName.c_str());
 
            // Generate only global variables defined by the pdf associated with this state
            std::unique_ptr<RooArgSet> globtmp{pdftmp->getObservables(*mc->GetGlobalObservables())};
            std::unique_ptr<RooDataSet> tmp{pdftmp->generate(*globtmp, 1)};
 
            // Transfer values to output placeholder
            globtmp->assign(*tmp->get(0));
         }
      }
 
      //    globalData->Print("v");
      //    unconditionalObs = *globalData->get();
      //    mc->GetGlobalObservables()->Print("v");
      //    delete globalData;
      //    cout << "toy data = " << endl;
      //    toyData->get()->Print("v");
 
      // get test stat at observed UL in observed data
      firstPOI->setVal(observedUL);
      double toyTSatObsUL = fc.GetTestStatSampler()->EvaluateTestStatistic(*toyData, tmpPOI);
      //    toyData->get()->Print("v");
      //    cout <<"obsTSatObsUL " <<obsTSatObsUL << "toyTS " << toyTSatObsUL << endl;
      if (obsTSatObsUL < toyTSatObsUL) // not sure about <= part yet
         CLb += (1.) / nToyMC;
      if (obsTSatObsUL <= toyTSatObsUL) // not sure about <= part yet
         CLbinclusive += (1.) / nToyMC;
 
      // loop over points in belt to find upper limit for this toy data
      double thisUL = 0;
      for (Int_t i = 0; i < parameterScan->numEntries(); ++i) {
         tmpPoint = (RooArgSet *)parameterScan->get(i)->clone("temp");
         double arMax = belt->GetAcceptanceRegionMax(*tmpPoint);
         firstPOI->setVal(tmpPoint->getRealValue(firstPOI->GetName()));
         //   double thisTS = profile->getVal();
         double thisTS = fc.GetTestStatSampler()->EvaluateTestStatistic(*toyData, tmpPOI);
 
         //   cout << "poi = " << firstPOI->getVal()
         // << " max is " << arMax << " this profile = " << thisTS << endl;
         //      cout << "thisTS = " << thisTS<<endl;
         if (thisTS <= arMax) {
            thisUL = firstPOI->getVal();
         } else {
            break;
         }
      }
 
      /*
      // loop over points in belt to find upper limit for this toy data
      double thisUL = 0;
      for(Int_t i=0; i<histOfThresholds->GetNbinsX(); ++i){
         tmpPoint = (RooArgSet*) parameterScan->get(i)->clone("temp");
         cout <<"----------------  "<<i<<endl;
         tmpPoint->Print("v");
         cout << "from hist " << histOfThresholds->GetBinCenter(i+1) <<endl;
         double arMax = histOfThresholds->GetBinContent(i+1);
         // cout << " threshold from Hist = aMax " << arMax<<endl;
         // double arMax2 = belt->GetAcceptanceRegionMax(*tmpPoint);
         // cout << "from scan arMax2 = "<< arMax2 << endl; // not the same due to TH1F not TH1D
         // cout << "scan - hist" << arMax2-arMax << endl;
         firstPOI->setVal( histOfThresholds->GetBinCenter(i+1));
         //   double thisTS = profile->getVal();
         double thisTS = fc.GetTestStatSampler()->EvaluateTestStatistic(*toyData,tmpPOI);
 
         //   cout << "poi = " << firstPOI->getVal()
         // << " max is " << arMax << " this profile = " << thisTS << endl;
         //      cout << "thisTS = " << thisTS<<endl;
 
         // NOTE: need to add a small epsilon term for single precision vs. double precision
         if(thisTS<=arMax + 1e-7){
            thisUL = firstPOI->getVal();
         } else{
            break;
         }
      }
      */
 
      histOfUL->Fill(thisUL);
 
      // for few events, data is often the same, and UL is often the same
      //    cout << "thisUL = " << thisUL<<endl;
   }
   histOfUL->Draw();
   c1->SaveAs("one-sided_upper_limit_output.pdf");
 
   // if you want to see a plot of the sampling distribution for a particular scan point:
   /*
   SamplingDistPlot sampPlot;
   int indexInScan = 0;
   tmpPoint = (RooArgSet*) parameterScan->get(indexInScan)->clone("temp");
   firstPOI->setVal( tmpPoint->getRealValue(firstPOI->GetName()) );
   toymcsampler->SetParametersForTestStat(tmpPOI);
   SamplingDistribution* samp = toymcsampler->GetSamplingDistribution(*tmpPoint);
   sampPlot.AddSamplingDistribution(samp);
   sampPlot.Draw();
      */
 
   // Now find bands and power constraint
   Double_t *bins = histOfUL->GetIntegral();
   TH1F *cumulative = (TH1F *)histOfUL->Clone("cumulative");
   cumulative->SetContent(bins);
   double band2sigDown, band1sigDown, bandMedian, band1sigUp, band2sigUp;
   for (int i = 1; i <= cumulative->GetNbinsX(); ++i) {
      if (bins[i] < RooStats::SignificanceToPValue(2))
         band2sigDown = cumulative->GetBinCenter(i);
      if (bins[i] < RooStats::SignificanceToPValue(1))
         band1sigDown = cumulative->GetBinCenter(i);
      if (bins[i] < 0.5)
         bandMedian = cumulative->GetBinCenter(i);
      if (bins[i] < RooStats::SignificanceToPValue(-1))
         band1sigUp = cumulative->GetBinCenter(i);
      if (bins[i] < RooStats::SignificanceToPValue(-2))
         band2sigUp = cumulative->GetBinCenter(i);
   }
   cout << "-2 sigma  band " << band2sigDown << endl;
   cout << "-1 sigma  band " << band1sigDown << " [Power Constraint)]" << endl;
   cout << "median of band " << bandMedian << endl;
   cout << "+1 sigma  band " << band1sigUp << endl;
   cout << "+2 sigma  band " << band2sigUp << endl;
 
   // print out the interval on the first Parameter of Interest
   cout << "\nobserved 95% upper-limit " << interval->UpperLimit(*firstPOI) << endl;
   cout << "CLb strict [P(toy>obs|0)] for observed 95% upper-limit " << CLb << endl;
   cout << "CLb inclusive [P(toy>=obs|0)] for observed 95% upper-limit " << CLbinclusive << endl;
}